Skip to content

About Tally & Tell

We count the stars customers give the businesses they buy from, hire and visit. Then we show you every review behind the count.

The idea, in three lines

  1. Customers rate a business from 1 to 5 stars and say what happened.
  2. We add up the stars in the open and show how they split.
  3. You read the reviews behind the number before you order, book or sign.

Why bother

Before you hand a company your money, you want to know how it treated the customers before you. Did the quote hold? Did the work get done on the day? Did anyone pick up the phone when something broke?

Reviews answer that only if nobody can buy them. A lot of review sites make their money from the businesses they rate: paid badges, awards, better placement. Here, no business can pay to delete a review or move its score.

Four promises

  1. Each review written here passes a human moderator first. Not a filter: a person.
  2. Reviews appear as their authors wrote them. A business can answer in public; it can’t edit a word.
  3. Money doesn’t delete reviews and doesn’t move scores.
  4. Scores are simple arithmetic, the stars of published reviews averaged, with the full formula laid out on How it works.

The coverage

Businesses across the US, split into 22 categories: vets and movers, law firms and gyms, insurers, tractor dealers and a long list in between. Open the category list.

Reach us

A question, a correction or a press request? Send it our way.

Photo credits

The photos on this site come from Unsplash. With thanks to the photographers:

Erik Mclean, stevosdisposable, Paul Kansonkho, Devon MacKay, Adam Winger, Stephen Crane, Luis Castro, Gene Gallin.