From pending to live
Every review written on Tally & Tell takes the same three steps:
- Pending. It lands in the moderation queue. It isn’t public yet.
- Read. One of our moderators holds it up to the review guidelines.
- Decided. Yes: it goes on the company’s page and into the score. No: it stays out of both.
What the moderator looks at:
- Is it first-hand? It has to describe a real dealing with that exact company: an order, a booking, a visit or a quote.
- Out it goes: any link, phone number, threat, hate speech or personal detail about a staff member.
- Red flags: one person posting again and again, or a review that traces back to the company’s staff or a competitor.
- The limit: 1 review per company, per reviewer, every 30 days.
And what the company can do with a review once it’s up:
- Can: answer any review in public.
- Can’t: edit it, hide it or delete it.
- Can’t: pay to change how it’s handled.
A 1-star review goes through exactly the process a 5-star review does. No extra hoops.
The score math
Score = the plain average of the stars in a company’s published reviews, rounded to 1 decimal. No estimates, no weighting by payment, no adjustments by hand.
Color kicks in at 5 published reviews. Under that, the number still shows, in grey and labeled Still counting, since a handful of reviews can swing it a long way.
| Band | Range | Looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Loved | 4.5 – 5.0 | 4.7 |
| Liked | 4.0 – 4.4 | 4.2 |
| Lukewarm | 3.0 – 3.9 | 3.4 |
| Disliked | 2.0 – 2.9 | 2.5 |
| Panned | under 2.0 | 1.6 |
Buying vs. service
Each reviewer tells us what the dealing was: a purchase, a price check or quote, or a job they hired the company for. Once enough answers are in, the page splits the score in two, one for buying and one for service. Plenty of companies nail one and miss the other.
Detail scores and quote vs. bill
Reviewers can also score four details: being clear and upfront, value for money, how smooth and on time it went, and quality. Two yes-or-no questions go with them: did the bill match the quote, and did any extra fees pop up? Each of these appears once 5 customers have answered it.
Ranked lists
Sorting by rating uses a sort value that weighs the number of reviews, too. The reason: 3 perfect reviews shouldn’t jump ahead of 40 excellent ones.
The method: each company starts with 5 imaginary reviews of 3.5 stars. As real reviews come in, they outweigh the imaginary ones and pull the sort value toward the company’s real average.
sort value = (3.5 × 5 + every star tallied) ÷ (5 + reviews tallied)
Where the sort value counts: the order of a sorted list. Where it never shows: the score on a company’s page, which stays the plain average.
Three review sources
Every review carries a line that says where it came from:
- Review left on Tally & Tell: no middleman. The customer wrote it and sent it on this site.
- Gathered with the company's own feedback form, from its customers: the company asked for the feedback and forwarded the answers to us. Our rule: no feedback the company hand-picked, edited or paid for.
- From another review platform: first posted by the customer on a different review site, and shown here unchanged from that version.
Listings & claims
Every listing starts from business information we gather and verify: the name, address, phone number and website.
Company closed, or can’t be confirmed anymore? We hide the listing rather than delete it, so its reviews survive.
- Price of claiming a listing: $0.
- What it unlocks: corrected details and public answers to customers.
- What it changes in the score: nothing.
The Report link
Every review has a Report link. Use it when a review breaks the guidelines, is about the wrong company, or doesn’t look genuine to you.
What happens next: a moderator looks at every report, then removes the review, keeps it, or asks the reviewer for more detail. The review stays visible while we look.