Skip to content

Review guidelines

Four things make a review useful, eight things keep one off the site, and four rules bind businesses. Same rules for everyone.

4 marks of a good review

  • First-hand. A dealing you had with this company yourself, in the last few years or thereabouts: an order, a hire, a booking or a quote.
  • Specific. Say what you bought or had done. Did the bill match the quote? Was it on time? How did they deal with a problem? Details tell the next customer more than adjectives do.
  • Fair. Report what happened and how they treated you. Be as blunt as you like about the experience; leave the name-calling out.
  • Long enough. Between 40 and 3000 characters.

8 things we don’t publish

  • Insider reviews: by an employee or relative of the company, by anyone it pays, or by any of those at a competitor.
  • Rewarded reviews: written for a discount, a gift, a payment, a prize-draw entry or any other perk.
  • The wrong target: reviews of another company, or of a manufacturer, marketplace seller or payment provider instead of the company itself.
  • Repeats: more than 1 review of one company from one person in any 30-day window.
  • Ways to reach someone: a link, a phone number or an email address, or the full name or contact details of anyone on staff.
  • Abuse: a threat, harassment, hate speech, swearing aimed at a person, or anything sexual.
  • Borrowed words: text copied from somewhere else, or written by AI tools instead of from your own experience.
  • Accusations of a crime: those go to the authorities, not here. Your own account of what happened to you stays welcome.

4 rules for businesses

Ask every customer for a review? Go ahead. These four moves, though, are banned:

  • Incentives: anything of value offered for a review, or for a good one only.
  • Cherry-picking: inviting only satisfied customers, or steering the unhappy ones away from reviewing.
  • Self-reviews: reviews of its own business or a rival’s, whether the owner, staff, family or a hired agency writes them.
  • Pressure: pushing or threatening a reviewer until a review is edited or removed.

Break one of these to get a review, and that review comes down.

Rulebook: 16 CFR Part 465, the Federal Trade Commission’s consumer review rule.

Decisions & second looks

  • Who decides? A moderator, for every review written on Tally & Tell, before the public sees it.
  • Rejected? The reason goes on file.
  • Disagree? Write to us with the company’s name and the email address you reviewed with. A moderator will review the call.