

4.8
Pick a bar to filter the reviews below.
Selling your coins shouldn’t be frustrating – but often it is.
Coinfully (coinfully.


Thomas E.
From start to finish Braden and his staff made the process simple and easy. Sending pictures of the coins and getting an appraisal within the next day I was surprised. Then given the option to mail the coins and the process was simple an easy. Totally Impressed!!!
Hi Thomas, Thank you so much for sharing your experience! Braden and the team were so happy to hear your kind words. We work hard to take the guesswork out of the process and make things as easy as possible from the very beginning. We’re so glad you found us and that we had the opportunity to work with you! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Shin S.
The Coinfully team is wonderful. From first contact to sending them our coins, they were patient and kind. We had a lot of questions that they answered without hesitation. The whole process was no pressure. After our first appraisal, we decided to wait and watch the market. They happily provided us valuation updates as the market shifted. Shipping and payment were easy and fast. 100% great experience.
Hi Shin, Thank you so much for sharing your kind words! You did the right thing for you, and that’s most important. We’re happy to work on your timeline and advise based on your goals and needs. It was our pleasure staying in touch. You asked all the right questions along the way, and we’re so glad everything came together when the time was right! We truly appreciate your trust in Coinfully and the opportunity to work with you and your collection. Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
James W.
The process was so easy. I sent pictures of several of my Morgan Silver dollars and received an offer the next day. We I agreed to a very reasonable price and shipped the dollars, I was paid that night.
Hi James, Thank you so much for sharing your experience! We really enjoyed getting to see the history and quality represented in your Morgan Silver Dollars. We’re glad everything came together so smoothly and that we had the opportunity to work with you and your collection! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Darren G.
Super honest with valuations and upfront about the process. Wired money as promised and beat my local coin shop offers by miles!
Hi Darren, Thank you so much for sharing this! We believe trust is earned through honest communication and following through on our commitments. We appreciate you, and would be happy to work with you again anytime! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Susan H.
First off, I was very nervous about going with an online company to sell my mother‘s gold coin jewelry. I looked Coinfully up on trustpilot and Google reviews and decided to go through with the process after reading positive reviews. I submitted pictures of the jewelry and their weights through email, received a quote within 24 hours and a follow up phone call. I ended up having to call them a couple times for different things and they were always very responsive, professional and helpful. I sent the jewelry UPS overnight and by noon the next day, I had the money in the bank. I feel the quote that they gave me was fair. I ended up paying about 13% in fees from the total value and considering I never wanted to sell coins because I know zero about them, this was a fair exchange for me. They even reimbursed me for the overnight shipping, which I did not expect. Five stars, excellent experience.
Hi Susan, Thank you so much for sharing your experience! We know how difficult it can be to make an important decision when it comes to family and finances, especially when navigating the coin market for the first time. Providing a personalized and fair experience to every collector is incredibly important to us. Every collection is different, so pricing and terms are determined individually based on the material, market, and logistics involved. We’re grateful you found us and trusted our team with your mother’s collection. It’s wonderful to hear that you felt supported throughout the process and had an excellent experience! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Rich H.
Old School Service, Accurate Information, Fair Pricing, Excellent Customer Service..I would recommend Coinfully to anyone who has collectable coins or currency they want to possibly sell and just want good honest feedback.
Hi Rich, Thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience and for the recommendation! We believe good business begins with honest communication, and having straightforward conversations makes everyone feel more confident to make important decisions. It was a pleasure working with you and we truly appreciate your trust in Coinfully! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Scott S.
If you need a quick turn around, personal service, and fair pricing, check Coinfully out.
Hi Scott, Thank you so much for the recommendation! We truly appreciate you choosing Coinfully and taking the time to share your experience! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Tim H.
Really appreciate the smooth, transparent and fair process of dealing with these guys. They were upfront about how they priced out my lot and why their offer was what it was. Zero pressure to sell and willing to talk about individual pieces. It was smoother and more pleasant than the local shops I've tried dealing with. From submitting an appraisal inquiry to seeing money in my bank account was less than 48 hours. Highly recommend! They are the first one's I'll come to next time for sure.
Hi Tim, Thank you so much for taking the time to leave such a thoughtful review! We’re glad the operation felt smooooth from start to finish. We believe the more informed you are, the better the experience and outcome tend to be. It was our pleasure working with you, and we truly appreciate your trust. Drop us a line anytime! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team