
4.4
Pick a bar to filter the reviews below.
With 10 Locations, our stores have the largest inventory offered at the best prices.
The Castle Jewelry (thecastlejewelry.




Yogesh M.
Review is for their gun store. It’s a common business. I am writing this review to warn others about the shockingly unprofessional and careless service I received from **The Castle Arms**. If you value your time, money, and sanity, steer clear of this company. On **March 13, 2025**, I placed an order for a CZ457 firearm. Immediately after placing the order, I noticed no confirmation email or details in my account. Concerned, I reached out to their customer support, who casually replied, *“Good morning, Yogesh. I have received your order. Thank you.”* No order number was provided until I explicitly asked for it. By **March 17**, I still had no shipping updates, so I inquired again. Their response? A dismissive, *“It looks like they cancelled the order and it has been refunded. I was not here on Friday so I am unsure why. I do apologize for the inconvenience.”* Let that sink in: **They cancelled my order without explanation, notification, or accountability**. To add insult to injury, this firearm was meant for my daughter, who had been eagerly waiting for it. When I pleaded with them to reinstate the order—even offering to reprovide my credit card information and emphasizing, *“I don’t need money back, I need the firearm”*—they ignored my request entirely. Not a single attempt was made to resolve the issue. They just told me that I can buy it now for $150 more than what I purchased for. **Key Issues with The Castle Arms:** 1. **Zero Transparency**: They cancelled my order without any prior notice or explanation. 2. **Abysmal Communication**: Their support team either lacks training or simply doesn’t care. Responses were vague, unhelpful, and devoid of empathy. 3. **No Accountability**: The representative admitted they “didn’t know why” the order was cancelled and made no effort to find out. 4. **Disregard for Customers**: My daughter’s excitement and my willingness to work with them meant nothing. They chose the lazy route—refunding without resolving. **Do NOT trust this company** with your business. Their incompetence and indifference will leave you frustrated and empty-handed. Save yourself the headache and shop elsewhere.
Shelly M.
I have not recieved my ring, we ordered and paid for it 14th January i have sent so many emails and no responce. I am gutted if i have been scammed with this.
Steve L.
I ordered a ring the first part of March. On March 19th, 2022 the item arrived at thier facility here in the United States. It is now 45 plus days later and the ring is still there. The site says it usually takes 17 days, it has been 45 plus. When i reach out to them they were responding back, but since April 17th, I have heard nothing. Money down the drain. Never will order from them again.
Hello Steve, I believe you may have us confused with another company. Possibly one called Jewelcastle.co? We did not have any online orders placed on the 19th through thecastlejewelry.com and we certainly do not have any outstanding shipments that are over a month old presently. In any case, you are welcome to provide me the order number and I can take a closer look. Ours will feature a 4 digit number, something like #1890 and does not include any letters like "JC". If your order number does contain "JC" before the number, it most likely was from jewelcastle.co and we have no affiliation with that company. Several of their customers have confused us with them when they reach out wondering where their orders are and unfortunately they are not easy to get a hold of. Feel free to give me a call at 859-309-0041 to discuss further or shoot me an email at [email protected] thanks, Matt at The Castle Jewelry Online
Candace T.
I've only visited The Castle once and it was to sell a piece of jewelry. Unfortunately I didn't know they would low ball and haggling was necessary to get a fair amount. I would advise anyone who sells or even pawns to have your items appraised first. Granted, they are in business to make money but if a customer discovers they've been 'taken' that's a customer that won't return.
Fidelis.shiques
I purchased jewellery and can't complain.best products
Margie
I purchased a mens ring for a Christmas gift from their Beechmont Road location. I asked about resizing and was told to just bring it back for free resizing if needed. A few days later, I took the ring to have it resized. The woman at the counter replied that they don't do resizing. I asked for the salesman who told me resizing was free. The woman then said they could send it out for sizing but it would take a few weeks. I do not recommend them.
Barry
Fantastic service from really nice people, always get my watches serviced and recently just hand a fantastic engagement ring! Great work!
Good morning Barry. Thank you for this wonderful review. We are glad you had such a wonderful experience. Be sure to tell all your family and friends about us!
Mary Laura S.
These people really care. Not only about the sale, but about you as a person. I'm a retired vet, and recently had a flash back problem. The Owner spent some of his personal time helping me get tru a very troubling time. Thank you. Jack